Offshore
OPINION OF THE WEEK: Swiss Stability Endures But Don't Get Complacent

Predictions have sometimes been made that Swiss private banking and finance is on a downward slope, as rival countries vie for the offshore centre crown. But the country is continuing to reinvent itself and stay competitive. The editor takes a quick tour around the issues.
It is always good to get a change of perspective and my regular
trips to Switzerland are an opportunity to do just that – I
am in Geneva to meet industry figures and for our tenth
annual
WealthBriefing Awards programme in the country.
Switzerland is still the world’s single largest offshore centre.
According to Boston
Consulting Group in 2021, the Alpine state was home
to $2.4 trillion of wealth.
Some of that figure might – in the intervening two years between
that BCG report and now – have wobbled a bit. And, as banks’
results have shown in past weeks, assets under management at
lenders are down. Even UBS, the titan of the Swiss banking
industry, couldn’t
escape the downward impact of falling markets last year. Even
so, for all the talk a decade ago (it feels longer!) of how the
Swiss banking industry was on the way out, that was a premature
judgement.
There has certainly been consolidation in the Swiss banking
sector, but not quite the “wave” of consolidation that is
sometimes talked about. At the top end, occasional mutterings
that UBS and Credit Suisse might tie the knot come up against the
regulatory and policymaking doubts about creating a mega-bank
with the “too-big-to-fail” characteristics that were top of mind
in the 2008 financial crash. Yes, Credit Suisse is going through
rough times, and has to restore its reputation and successfully
push through with risk and cost reductions. (As of the time of
going to press, the latest Credit
Suisse results were out, and that bank has a lot of work to
do in stemming outflows and rebuilding.) But Credit Suisse is
still a large player, albeit one under pressure.
Julius Baer did its share of M&A almost a decade ago, such as
the Merrill Lynch transactions in the UK, and it has built joint
ventures and built out business footprints in Southeast Asia,
among other places. The medium-sized players, such as Lombard
Odier, Pictet and Mirabaud, ended their old unlimited liability
ownership structures almost a decade ago, and now report their
financial figures. (Before, no such detail had to be given out,
to the frustration of journalists.) There's still quite
a rump, though, of old-fashioned private banks with unlimited
liability structures. I wonder how much longer they can
endure.
Switzerland has to some degree had to reinvent itself. There have
been legislative tweaks and an entry into the cross-border
Common Reporting Standard on information exchange about a decade
ago, which means that its old bank secrecy regime has ended, at
least for non-Swiss clients of Swiss banks (in the country, it is
still a criminal matter to disclose who local clients are).
Switzerland is now a fintech leader in certain respects:
consider firms such as Avaloq, Temenos and ERI Bancaire, for
example. And consider also how the Swiss “crypto valley” in Zug,
spilling over into Liechtenstein, has given the country
an edge in developing digital assets and associated
technologies using blockchain. Notwithstanding the falls in
bitcoin, stablecoins and other entities last year, the digital
assets space is not going away. In fact last year’s bankruptcy of
Bahamas-registered FTX, the crypto exchange, makes Switzerland
look relatively stable by comparison. The Swiss regulator, FINMA,
knows it cannot take any nonsense.
Almost exactly a year ago, the country chalked up a major “first”
– following the invasion of Ukraine, it backed the European Union
and US over sanctions against designated Russians. This has to
some extent made obvious what was bubbling under the surface for
a while, which is that Switzerland’s famed political neutrality
is fraying at the edges, but that's not necessarily a problem. It
had to make a decision. And yes, it may mean that a lot of
Russian money has decamped to places such as Dubai. (A friend of
mine who works in Asia told me that in Dubai airport, the lounges
echo to the sound of Russian voices.) Another issue, which will
take some care in managing, is that wealthy families in the Gulf
may feel that the region is less geopolitically volatile than it
was a few years ago, and therefore think there's less need to
park some of their assets in a safe place such as Switzerland.
The hotels and restaurants of Geneva and Zurich have made a good
living from Middle East clientele – some of that might possibly
change.
Also, Switzerland has been through a regulatory
overhaul of its external asset management sector, so there is
likely to be consolidation of EAMs and trust firms. From what I
have seen of some of the data, the number of trustees is already
down quite sharply. The number of EAMs, often set up by bankers
breaking away from old firms to be independent, has mushroomed.
However, in recent years policymakers have wanted to create
order, and whatever the consequences, new rules are with
us.
The famously independent-minded Alpine state knows that it must
not overdo the regulatory push, lest significant business
flees. (The UK, post-Brexit, must accept a similar calculation.)
Rival centres look enviously at Switzerland. And the neighbouring
European Union, which is pushing Switzerland to replace over a
hundred bilateral treaties with a framework pact, has been
playing hardball over matters such as Swiss immigration
restrictions and state aid. Switzerland has access to the EU
Single Market and is in the passport-free Schengen area, but
there’s always the risk that a row could damage that. It’s
unsurprising that the Swiss cast a nervous eye at the UK over
what could happen if there is a serious rupture with Brussels.
That relationship calls for delicate handling. And it also means
that Switzerland must forge strong links with other, non-EU hubs
such as the UK.
BCG argued in its 2021 report that in 2020, the rankings of
“leading cross-border” centres were, in descending order:
Switzerland, Hong Kong, Singapore, the US, the Channel Islands
and Isle of Man, the United Arab Emirates, the UK mainland,
Luxembourg, Monaco, and Liechtenstein. In 2025, BCG predicts the
following ranking: Hong Kong, Switzerland, Singapore, the US, the
UAE, the Channel Islands and Isle of Man, the UK mainland,
Luxembourg, Monaco, and Liechtenstein. BCG predicted that Hong
Kong, buoyed by the Wealth Connect links to the mainland, would
overtake Switzerland in these rankings by 2025. Perhaps BCG
hadn’t banked on Beijing's zero-Covid regime and its impact
on Hong Kong, or the dampening impact of China’s national
security law of 2020 on Hong Kong. That said, the momentum
appears to be with Asia for the medium term.
Even so, as I look out of my hotel across Lake Geneva, and meet
many of the figures in this industry, I am not sensing any
complacency or sense of dark forboding, either. This is a country
that has made much of the benefits of stability over the
centuries. Considering what the past few years have been like, it
is a priceless asset.